Society Health is a healthcare focused financial management company. We invest in healthcare providers of all types whose impact strengthens communities and promotes long-term growth.

The Decline of Independent Medical Practices: A Temporary Cycle or a Permanent Shift?

Introduction:

• Independent medical practice ownership is shrinking, raising the question: Is this a repeat of past cycles or a fundamental, permanent transformation?

• Previous declines in the 1990s and 2000s were driven by managed care and Medicare cuts.

• Today’s pressures—administrative burdens, Medicare reimbursement cuts, staffing shortages, and capital requirements—may signal deeper, more lasting changes.

• Investors in healthcare must grasp these trends to seize emerging opportunities, especially in a volatile industry.

Is This a Cycle or the End of Independent Practices?

Over the years, independent medical practices have gone through several periods of consolidation and decline. In the 1990s and early 2000s, the growth of managed care and Medicare reimbursement cuts pushed many small practices into mergers with larger hospital systems. For many, these shifts seemed like the end of the physician-owned practice model.

While there was a brief resurgence in the 2010s, driven by a desire among some physicians to regain autonomy, today’s challenges feel different. The combination of soaring administrative costs, staffing shortages, stagnating Medicare reimbursements, and rising inflationary pressures present a more complex and systemic problem than in previous decades. Practices that were already operating on razor-thin margins now face an environment where profitability seems elusive.

As the Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) points out, smaller practices, unlike hospital-owned systems, can’t weather economic downturns without cash reserves or cross-subsidization from other revenue sources​. Today’s landscape, impacted by unprecedented administrative complexity and workforce shortages, seems to represent a more permanent shift rather than a cyclical downturn​ .

Key Data Points:

• Medicare Reimbursement Declines: In 2024, CMS reduced Medicare payments by 1.69% after years of steady cuts. This follows a 3.37% cut earlier in the year, which was only partially mitigated​.

• Administrative Costs: Practices now spend nearly 16 hours per week on administrative tasks, a 50% increase from the early 2010s​.

• Staffing Shortages: A shortage of up to 124,000 physicians is projected by 2034, which particularly affects independent practices that struggle to compete for talent against large hospital systems​.

• Rising Operating Costs: The operating cost per full-time-equivalent (FTE) physician has increased by over 63% from 2013 to 2022, with no commensurate rise in reimbursement rates​ .

Detailed Analysis: What’s Different About Today’s Challenges?

Unlike the cyclical nature of past declines, today’s challenges suggest that we may be witnessing the beginning of a more permanent transformation.

1. Administrative Burdens
The administrative complexity surrounding billing, compliance, and electronic health record (EHR) systems has exploded in recent years. The MGMA estimates that independent practices now spend $12,811 per physician just to comply with the Medicare Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS)​. This is far from the relatively straightforward environment of the 1990s when physicians spent significantly more time on patient care than administration.

2. Declining Reimbursements
Medicare cuts were already a problem in the early 2000s, but the cuts today are compounded by inflation and rising labor costs. Despite a 63% increase in operational costs over the last decade, Medicare reimbursement rates have only inched up by 1.7%​. This gap puts a squeeze on profit margins, making it increasingly difficult for smaller practices to stay afloat without outside investment or hospital integration.

3. Staffing Shortages
The healthcare workforce shortage, exacerbated by the pandemic, is not only an operational issue but also a recruitment challenge. Independent practices often lose out to larger health systems that can offer higher pay and better benefits. A survey by MGMA found that 56% of medical practices cited staffing shortages as their biggest productivity roadblock​ .

4. Capital Investment Needs
Running an independent practice today requires heavy investment in not only physical infrastructure but also cybersecurity, compliance frameworks, and digital health systems. These costs deter new physicians from opening independent practices and push older practitioners toward selling their practices .

Example: Comparing a Small Practice in 2000 vs. 2024

Consider a small, independent orthopedic practice in 2000. Back then, Medicare cuts were concerning but manageable, and the administrative burdens were lower. Fast forward to 2024, and that same practice is grappling with significant Medicare payment reductions, increased administrative complexity from billing regulations, and the need to invest heavily in technology just to comply with federal mandates. The once-profitable practice is now exploring mergers with larger health systems, a move it previously resisted to maintain autonomy.

Strategic Insights for Investors: Navigating the Decline with Value-Building Strategies

For healthcare investors, these trends offer both opportunities and risks. As independent practices face mounting pressure, there are several strategies that can either capitalize on the trend toward consolidation or support independent practices through targeted investments.

Consolidation: Larger healthcare systems or private equity groups often acquire struggling independent practices to take advantage of economies of scale. Investors benefit from lower overhead costs, higher bargaining power with insurers, and access to more resources. However, the downside is the loss of physician autonomy, which may lead to discontent and turnover among practice owners and staff.

Technology Investments: Another approach is investing in technology that reduces administrative burden, such as artificial intelligence (AI)-driven billing systems or patient care management platforms. While this can improve operational efficiency, the challenge lies in the significant upfront costs and the long implementation timelines.

Aligning with Larger Healthcare Networks: Some practices may opt to align themselves with larger networks while maintaining a degree of independence. This gives them access to resources like staffing and technology without fully relinquishing control. However, this middle ground can still limit their autonomy and subject them to the corporate culture of the larger network.

Conclusion: The End of Independence or Just Another Chapter?

The decline in independent medical practice ownership might not be a simple cycle as in the past. Today’s combination of rising administrative burdens, declining reimbursements, staffing shortages, and increasing capital demands suggests that the independent practice model could be in permanent decline. For investors, however, this period presents significant opportunities. Whether through consolidation, strategic tech investments, or partnerships, there are ways to build value in this transitioning market.

For healthcare investors willing to adapt, the current landscape presents a wealth of opportunities, but understanding the risks is crucial. We may be entering a new era of healthcare, where only the most resourceful, efficient, and well-capitalized practices survive .

1  Becker's ASC Review, "5 Reasons Independent Practices Are Disappearing." September 2023. https://mail.beckersasc.com/asc-coding-billing-and-collections/5-reasons-independent-practices-are-disappearing.html

2  WCH Service Bureau, "Strengthening Independent Medical Practices." September 2024.https://insights.wchsb.com/2024/09/10/strengthening-independent-medical-practices

3  Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) Testimony, "Statement for the House Committee on Ways and Means Subcommittee on Health Hearing, ‘The Collapse of Private Practice: Examining the Challenges Facing Independent Medicine.’" May 23, 2024.